Jay Lake: Writer

Contact Me Home
>

[Links]

[links] Link salad can’t touch that

The comment thread in my post of yesterday on language etymology and word choicse is quite amazing — Go check it out.

A Whiff of Colonialism on the Spinrad column, and non-Eurocentric writing. The discussion isn’t the least bit about me, quite the opposite, but it does cause me to consider myself. This is a complex topic for me, because of my own background. I’m solidly in the privileged class of white, male, Anglo-Saxon, tall(ish), well-educated, well-employed, etc. etc. Yet I spent most of my childhood in non-white, non-Anglophone countries, and I have a non-white daughter growing up in my house. My experience of culture, privilege and race is far more complex than you could ever assume from seeing my face in an author photo, or reading my utterly English name on a book spine. Yet one of the reasons I’ve generally stopped talking about race and culture on this blog is that every time I do, a meaningful portion of readers see my name and face and assume I’m another clueless privileged white guy, and respond accordingly with either vitriol, scorn or earnest attempts at re-education. It’s hardly a tragedy for the public discourse that some privileged white guy’s words about race have been tuned out, but it saddens me personally to self-censor.

Syphilis: Menace to Industry — Classic poster art. Somehow I never quite thought of industrial productivity as a primary motivator for safe sex.

Constructing a marble machine — Impressive (and obsessive) as all get out. (Thanks to .)

Habitable Planets: Working the Odds — Drake, Drake, duck!

Still Taking Exception — Daniel Larison on American Exceptionalism, Obama, and his critics on the Right.

?otD: What color are your parachute pants?


3/11/2010
Writing time yesterday: 1 hours
Body movement: 30 minute stationary bike ride
Hours slept: 7.5 (solid)
This morning’s weigh-in: 231.4
Yesterday’s chemo stress index: 3/10
Currently reading: [between books]

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

Comments

  • Jaws

    March 11th, 2010 at 3:12 pm

    Jay, it could be worse. You could have a surname — courtesy of Ellis Island — that totally masks your non-Angloness. You could have a substantial part of your ethnicity arise through something that the government (but no one else, and in particular not ethnologists and/or biologists) calls “caucasian.” And you could have stood up, in military uniform, at an MLA panel on gender issues to ask a clarifying question because you couldn’t quite hear everything the speaker said.

    Sadly, none of that is hypothetical, and just reinforces my conclusion that the reason that alternate sexual preferences are so threatening to so many is that one can’t tell who the “enemy” is just by looking. (And that goes both directions.)

    • Cora

      March 11th, 2010 at 6:07 pm

      Since according to the other post, at least some of your ancestors were German, you’re probably better off with an anglicized surname. Because otherwise you’d be stuck being a representative of one of the few ethnicities it’s still okay to mock and insult and the only time you’d see someone with a name like yours in books, films, TV, etc… would be as a villain.

      What strikes me most about the racism/othering debate that has been breaking up again and again for the past two years or so is how utterly American-centric it is. Because outside the US, the conflict lines are not necessarily between white people and people of colour (which is what the US discourse frequently tends to boil down to, viewed from an outsider perspective) but often between ethnic groups which are the same race to an outside observer.

      This – along with having seen how quickly such race debates can get incredibly ugly – is why I largely stay out of the various reiterations of the racism/othering debate. Because it’s very much a US-centered debate. When writing, I do my best to include characters and worlds of diverse backgrounds, well aware that my notion of diversity may not necessarily match that in the US and elsewhere.

Leave a Reply

« | »